The workplace is probably not better for it. Employee satisfaction has suffered because of it. More stress has entered the workplace because of it. The Employee Relations folks have failed to find an acceptable substitute for it. No one ever talks about it – it just happens. What is this I speak of, you ask? Simply, the continued ostracization of the smokers – I mean really – where have the smokers gone and are we really better for it? I say No.
Let’s dispense with your quick assumptions – I am NOT a smoker and never have been with the exception of a periodic smoke when I drank. I will say that if I had a smoke when I drink now – I would be a smoker by default for my wife forces me to consume large amounts of wine – we have an unlimited budget in this area. Tangent.
I can recall the good old days of the early 90s when there was a smoking section in my company cafeteria. You know when the effective barrier was a freaking aisle with slightly more width and some ceiling fans running at a more rapid pace to improve air quality. While maintenance looked at fan speed as a better air circulator for the greater good, the smoker viewed this as training for the approaching winter months when they would be huddled together outside in a "designated smoking area" – cold, shivering yet puffing away at pleasure in a stick.
They knew what was coming – no longer being able to smoke inside but at a new outside designated smoking area. Let’s take a closer look at these areas if we can. Many companies decided to go with an area out back, down a ways maybe, perhaps the shipping and receiving deck now dubbed smoking and receiving by the smokers. The "down a ways" approach was the veiled way of the company suggesting – maybe you need to quit smoking and mix in an exercise regimen. They were not deterred – it was their smoke.
Back to the designated smoking areas – I am struck by the fact that the area always takes on a single syllable design – the smoke shack, the smoke room, the smoke deck, the smoke hut – no one ever names it the cancer canopy, cougher corner, COPD alley – no one ever tries to get money from tobacco companies to sponsor it. Why not get some funding here?
Enter the wellness program. Better insurance rates, gym memberships at a discount, free calorie counters – while the Employee Benefits professional champions this because he is a professional trainer on the side, has a meal replacement shake for lunch EVERYDAY and knows his body fat percentage like others know their address – the smoker screams, in a raspy voice, Why? They don’t want to count their steps, they don’t want to workout on a regular basis – they just want to know how many steps to the smoke shack for that is where their wellness resides. Simply examined, they are deferring the heavy breathing from the cardio equipment we use now to the end of their life.
I think we have really lost something in this ostracization of the smoker though. Smoking is diversity. Smoking brings people together that would not normally be together. It transcends gender, race, exempt and non-exempt, mail room and boardroom, marketing and operations. I think we have segregated the smoker because as non-smokers we are completely envious of the bond this fraternity holds and we have nothing that compares to it. Absolutely nothing. We have tried with our golf leagues, fantasy sports leagues, departmental luncheons, corporate challenge events, whatever but in our heart of hearts they all fall short and we know it. These things are limited and seasonal.
I think all of us have caught ourselves, from time to time, sneaking a peek at the smokers area and all the allure it holds – wishing we smoked. We see the kind of strange mail room/copy room guy named Lawrence with like the Dudley Doright voice – never call him Larry – having a conversation with an Executive VP – the head legal counsel chatting with the ap clerk who has the fascination with Mickey Mouse and we want some of that. Smoking is the great equalizer.
We bring a cake on a co-workers birthday and call it thoughtful, they bring cartons for the same and call it personal sacrifice. We have surface conversations with co-workers – "How you doing, Bill?" and could care less what the answer is – they know each others kids by name and the namebrand they’re packing. It really is as if we are just pissed that we can’t practice our respective vice at work. They can smoke, why can’t I have a gambling area out back too?
We need to control this jealousy and embrace the smoker code. At its foundation, the smoker code offers bridge building diversity and strong personal relationships at work. They see each other in a relaxed atmosphere and can be themselves – stress free, secure, transparent with a smoky film. No wonder the smoker loves their job – we can’t continue to take this away. Maybe we all need an occasional puff or at a minimum just to go sit out there and hold a lit cigarette and inhale the positve vibe. Just throw some Febreeze in your damn gymbag. Improved morale has a cost.
Look, it is not the smoker that has trouble with the non-smoker it is the non-smoker who really has the dilemna. Let’s give them their designated smoking area, continue searching in vain for its equal and press on doing the work that the company hired us to perform. Even better, seek to understand what can we learn from these people – let’s take the best of what they practice with a smoke in their hand and apply to our non-smoker ways.






On several occasions at my last job I would be in long drawn out meetings only to have the plant manager step out to the “smoke deck” and after spending only 10 minutes with his fellow smoking buddies, return to revise every decision made prior to his “smoke break”. Is it the smoke or the support group effect that gave him that sudden burst of enlightenment? In late 2006 we removed all the chairs in our meeting rooms to promote shorter more effective meetings (sort of like what they do on the smoke deck). Last year we promoted the “brain storming meetings” that would last no more than 15 minutes and focus on a specific topic (sort of like what they do on the smoke deck). Those who spent time on the “smoke deck” had more input when it came to plant decisions than most of the management staff. While it has a very positive effect on those who belong to this smoking society, the negative effect on the non-smoking middle and upper management is devastating. So I agree, we should infuse our daily work practices with the best of what’s happening on the smoke deck….even though history says it will only work with a smoke.
No, you want to know the real reason why we non-smokers are so “envious” of the smoker? It’s not because they have that special bond with others in the company. It’s because they get paid the same amount (or more) than their non-smoking co-workers but the non-smokers get work dumped on them because they are actually at their desks. I have worked with and for many smokers over the years. The bottom line is, when the CFO comes looking for Puffing Paul to get a report and he’s on the never-ending smoke break, guess who gets the request. That’s right, it’s Smoke-free Suzy who’s busting her butt to cover her already overwhelming workload!
I’ve often considered taking up smoking just so I can goof off 20 times a day and still collect the same paycheck! Am I a bit bitter about this topic? You’re darned right I am! If companies continue to tolerate this behavior, then non-smokers should get some benefits too. They should ban together and have a walking break; it’s healthy and allows you clear your thoughts. Then maybe when NO ONE is at their desks, someone in upper management will wake up.
Great Post but I have a question for Tracie Z. What stops you from going to hang out with your smoking co-workers, heck, just carry a pack of cigs with you and you can take those 20 minute breaks too. This way the work does not get dumped on you and you can give up you bitterness. It is way worse for you than the smoking is for the smokers.
Sorry, thats all I have time for I need a smoke break.
Interestingly enough, a group of us non-smokers at my last corporate gig decided the smoke breaks were getting out of hand. A few key personnel would vacate the building quietly, yet all at the same time to make their “smoke conference” on time – it was starting to be a real drag (pun intended)… So we non-smokers came up with a plan…, every time the smokers went missing, we would take a ten- to fifteen-minute UNO break. That’s right, we would crowd into a small conference room and play killer UNO for as long as the smokers were away from their desks.
We formed our own camaraderie.
We had a trophy – a slate of wood – as in, “who’s bringing the wood today?” that each round winner signed their name on, in sharpie, and took proudly with them when they returned to their offices or cubicles until the next smoker’s break.
Pretty soon, the smokers were jealous of us, actually, they thought we were pathetic…, but it was fun to watch them sneak out and then we would sneak off to our UNO hideaway. The crowning glory was when the game grew to about 13 of us and we had to move it to the lunch room where the CEO walked in on us and asked us what we were doing – “Taking our smoke break.” You looked at us blankly, shook his head, and walked out without his coffee refill.
Camaraderie is not dead. It’s just more creative now.